About Us

The Key West Key Lime Pie Co. offers a variety of products from our delicious award winning pies to our decadent key lime pie bars.

Here at Key West Key Lime Pie Co. all of our pies are made with natural ingredients and handmade. We live by our motto "If we don't make it, we don't sell it!"

Come visit the store and watch our pie makers in action making pies, bars and more before your very eyes! Our 100 year old recipe is what makes our pies unique and keeps our customers coming back for more!

Not visiting Key West soon? Shop online!

NEW & EXCITING! Get your Sweet Pete's treats at Key Lime Pie Co! Be sure to stop in and get your favorite sweets in Key West!

511 Greene Street,
Key West FL 33040
Phone: 1-800-507-4337 

Hours: 10am - 10pm Daily 
Christmas Eve 10am - 4pm
Closed: Thanksgiving Day and Christmas Day